
How to Choose a Dog Trainer

Choosing the right trainer for you and your dog
You love your dog. You want the best for them—the healthiest food, the tastiest treats, the softest beds.
You want the best dog trainer, too, but with so much conflicting information and advice swirling around out there, how do you choose?
2 things you should know
1. Dog training is an unregulated industry
Unlike your doctor, lawyer, and CPA, dog trainers have no official regulating body. That means no required education, no enforced best practices, and no ethics oversight. The dog training industry hasn’t yet matured out of its Wild West phase.
The results are vast variations in dog trainers’ skills, knowledge, and methodologies–and a confusing chaos of advice. (Think doctors before the medical board existed to ban leeches, or attorneys before the bar formed to hold professionals accountable for ethics violations.)
2. Methodology matters
While the lack of regulation means trainers don’t have to adhere to the science of behaviour and training, the science itself is clear about how dogs learn and how best to teach them.
Decades of research show that reward-based, force-free, kind dog training is the only approach to changing behaviour that comes without unwanted behavioural side effects, risk of physical harm, and potential damage to the relationship between dogs and their people.
In fact, leading veterinary bodies like American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB), American College of Veterinary Behaviorists (ACVB), American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA), and World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) agree that reward-based training is the safest, most effective, and humane way to train all dogs, regardless of breed, age, size, or temperament.
Unfortunately, due to the lack of professional education and regulation, outdated practices continue to persist.
3 tips for screening a professional dog trainer
1. Listen to language
In an unregulated industry, language matters. Hire a dog trainer who is committed to the exclusive use of reward-based, force-free, fear-free training. Your trainer might also use terms like positive training or positive reinforcement.
Many trainers will mix the above with outdated methodology, so watch out for terms like “balanced” and “alpha” or claims to match the method to the dog. The science of animal learning applies to all dogs, regardless of size, breed, or personality, and all dogs deserve to be trained without discomfort, pain, fear, or coercion. A professional dog trainer will not need to use such approaches to get the job done.
2. Beware training guarantees
Professional organisations like Karen Pryor Academy (KPA), Pet Professional Guild (PPG), and Victoria Stilwell Academy for Dog Training & Behavior, prohibit the unethical practice of guaranteeing specific training results. Doing so is a false promise; no one can guarantee the behaviour of another living being capable of independent decision making.
Check that any trainer you consider hiring voluntarily commits to high ethical standards through membership, certification or accreditation with reputable professional organisations such as Karen Pryor Academy (KPA), Pet Professional Guild (PPG), Victoria Stilwell Positively Dog Training (VSPDT), and Alberta Force Free Alliance (AFFA). These organisations promote humane, force-free training and hold their members or credentialed professionals to established standards of conduct.
Always verify their current standing and the training methods they use.
Though behavioural guarantees are a red flag, your trainer should guarantee excellent client service, a supportive, judgment-free learning environment, customized training plans to address your goals and fit your lifestyle, regular, constructive feedback and ongoing support between training sessions to set you and your dog up for success.
3. Look for credentials
Professional learning isn’t yet required, but serious professional dog trainers seek it out—because you and your dog deserve effective, up-to-date methods that do no harm.
Dogs trainers graduated from Karen Pryor Academy, The Academy For Dog Trainers, Peaceable Paws Academies, Victoria Stilwell Academy for Dog Training & Behavior, DogNostics Education, Companion Animal Sciences Institute, Delta Institute — Australia, Canine Principles or Institute of Modern Dog Trainers.
Or hold competency-assessed professional certifications or accreditations from the Pet Professional Accreditation Board, and International Positive Dog Training Association.
These trainers and behaviour consultants have completed a comprehensive, science-based course of study covering canine learning theory, training protocols, mechanical skills, and behavioural problem solving. And pro trainers commit themselves to ongoing professional development, seeking each year to keep their skills and knowledge current.
5 questions to ask before you hire
1. What are your dog training qualifications?
Green flag answers: Qualifications from reputable, science-based, force-free educational institutions or accreditation bodies, such as:
KPA-CTP - Karen Pryor Academy
KPA SCB - Specialist, Canine Behavior
CTC - The Academy for Dog Trainers
PMCT - Peaceable Paws Academies
VSA-CDT - Victoria Stilwell Academy for Dog Training & Behavior
DN-DTC or DN-DBC - DogNostics Education
PDT or CBST - Companion Animal Sciences Institute
CTT-A, PCT-A or PCBC-A - Pet Professional Accreditation Board
MDI CPDT - Delta Institute, Australia
IMDT - Institute of Modern Dog Trainers
FFCP - Fear Free Certified Professional — Animal Trainer
CCUI - Certified Control Unleashed Instructor
CBATI-KA/ KSA - Certified Behavior Adjustment Training Instructor — Knowledge Assessed or Knowledge and Skills Assessed
CSAT - Certified Separation Anxiety Trainer
CSAP-BC - Certified SA Pro Behaviour Consultant
CARE-TC - Cooperative Care Trainer Certificate
FDM / LFDM - Family Dog Mediator / Licensed Family Dog Mediator
FPPE - Licensed Family Paws Parent Educator
ACE Trainer/Practitioner - Animal Centred Education Trainer/Practitioner
SDC - Service Dog Coach
Atlas Certified Trainer - Atlas Assistance Dogs Certified Trainer
CNWI - Certified Nose Work Instructor
CTDI - Certified Trick Dog Instructor
Recognised professional qualifications from Canine Principles
Bonus points for ongoing professional education like seminars, conferences, and additional certification programs. Look for a trainer who values lifelong learning, stays current with scientific research and recognises the limitations of their expertise.
Red flag answers: Self-taught, mentorship (without a reputable school’s backing), years of experience (again, without a reputable school graduation).
Be aware that organisations that endorse punishment-based training methods also issue credentials. Take the time to research the training philosophy, educational requirements and ethical standards behind each credential.
2. What kind of training methodology do you use?
Green flag answers: Only reward-based, force-free fear-free, or positive-reinforcement based training.
Red flag answers: Balanced training, traditional training, it depends on the dog, or corrections or punishment-based training.
3. What kind of training tools do you recommend?
Green flag answers: Training treats and treat pouches, clickers, toys, well-fitted non-restrictive harnesses, busy toys/ food puzzles/ lick mats/ enrichment items, fixed-length leashes and long line leashes, flat collars, baby gates and exercise pens, training mat or platform, target sticks, well-fitted basket muzzles.
Bonus points if the trainer can explain why they recommend particular tools, how they benefit your dog and how they select equipment based on your dog's individual needs, comfort and safety.
Red flag answers: Shock, stim, or e-collars, prong/ pinch collars, choke collars, spray bottles, shake cans, throw chains, citronella and other spray collars, ultrasonic anti-bark devices, anti-bark collars, Pet Corrector sprays (compressed air) or air horns or other noise-making devices used to frighten or startle dogs, tightening or restrictive harnesses designed to cause discomfort, Scat mats (electronic shock mats), training sticks or whips, rolled-up newspapers or towel to ‘bonk the dog on the head’.
Recognise that aversive training equipment is sometimes marketed using misleading language. Aversive tools and techniques are often described using reassuring terms such as gentle stimulation, communication tools, taps, reminders, pressure and release, or just getting the dog's attention. Changing the terminology does not change how the equipment functions or how your dog experiences it.
Training tools should facilitate learning, not force compliance through pain, fear, discomfort or intimidation.
4. What do you do when a dog makes a mistake?
Green flag answers: We try again; we adjust the situation or environment to set the dog up for success; we adjust the training plan, steps/ criteria to work at the dog’s level or make it easier for him to get it right.
Red flag answers: We apply a correction (show them who’s in charge, give a collar correction, reprimand, spray from a squirt bottle, etc.)
5. What is your training guarantee? How long will it take to get results?
Green flag answers: That it’s considered unethical to guarantee specific training results or a specific timeframe for reaching them. That they guarantee to do everything in their power to set you and your dog up for the best success and to get you there as quickly as possible.
Red flag answers: Any guarantee of a specific outcome; i.e. a guarantee that your dog will or will not do something. Real training results require time and effort. Be wary of quick fix promises and miraculous easy buttons. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
1 more thing…
Your dog trainer should be dog and people-friendly
You deserve to feel comfortable, heard, and supported by your dog trainer—never criticized or judged. Your dog trainer should be actively engaged with you and your dog, and as invested in your training success as you are.
And though dog training takes time and effort, you and your dog should both enjoy the process. Training can—and should be—fun.
In short, if the relationship doesn’t feel right, trust your gut and keep looking.
Ready to choose your dog trainer?
If you’re ready for a professional dog trainer dedicated to the best possible results for you and your dog, we’d love to hear from you.
Contact Us
Location
Henrico, VirginiaCall Us
(804) 506-0550